Skip to main content

The Uprising Review

Consensus Review19 independent sources

The Uprising

A historical drama directed by Paul Greengrass centered on the 1381 Peasants' Revolt in England.

6.4/10
MIXED RECEPTION
✅ 53% Positive (10 sources)⚠️ 0% Mixed (0 sources)❌ 47% Negative (9 sources)

How This Score Is Calculated

  • Sources analysed: 19 reviews
  • Raw weighted average: 6.4
  • Formula: Σ(score × weight) ÷ Σ(weight)
  • Review period: 2026-09-08 to 2026-09-19

Algorithmically calculated from source data. No manual adjustments.

  • Most reviewed featureLead Performance (19/19)
  • Most praisedAndrew Garfield's performance
  • Most criticisedRobin Hood twist / Script
  • Reviewer consensus levelContested
Mixed ReceptionHistorical DramaPolarising Narrative

The Uprising enters a crowded field of 2026 historical dramas, attempting to ground the legend of Robin Hood within the visceral reality of the 1381 Peasants' Revolt. Paul Greengrass applies his signature documentary-style filmmaking to a period setting, aiming to bridge the gap between medieval class struggle and contemporary political discourse.

However, the production occupies a contentious space in the current film landscape. While audiences and critics remain divided on the film's tonal consistency and narrative choices, it serves as a primary example of the ongoing industry trend of 'revisionist' historical storytelling, frequently compared to other recent, similarly dour folk-hero deconstructions.

🔧 Key Specifications

Specifications sourced from reviewer mentions. Verify with production notes.

  • Director: Paul Greengrass
  • Lead Actor: Andrew Garfield
  • Setting: 1381 Peasants' Revolt
  • Runtime: 128 minutes
  • Cinematography: Handheld/Shaky-cam
  • Score: Volker Bertelmann

📊 What Reviewers Say — Feature by Feature

6 features evaluated across 19 sources.

✅
Lead PerformanceAndrew Garfield is universally praised for a committed, nuanced, and sensitive portrayal that provides the film's emotional anchor.
19 / 19
✅
Battle SequencesThe visceral, high-energy combat scenes are frequently cited as masterfully staged and physically engaging.
12 / 19
❌
Robin Hood TwistThe narrative decision to link the story to a Robin Hood origin is widely described as forced, unnecessary, and chronologically inaccurate.
8 / 19
❌
ScreenplayReviewers frequently critique the script for being under-written, emotionally vacant, and reliant on predictable, heavy-handed political allegory.
7 / 19
❌
CinematographyThe signature shaky-cam style receives mixed reactions, with many finding it nauseating or distracting during fight sequences.
6 / 19
❌
Visual EffectsThe film is criticised for inconsistent, synthetic, and rudimentary digital crowd extensions and CGI.
4 / 19

👍 Key Strengths

  • Andrew Garfield performance
  • Visceral action choreography
  • Production design
  • Thematic political resonance

👎 Key Weaknesses

  • Forced Robin Hood origin twist
  • Shaky-cam cinematography
  • Under-developed screenplay
  • Inconsistent CGI

⚡ Where Reviewers Disagreed

The following areas saw meaningful disagreement across sources.

  • Cinematography: 6 sources praised the 'innovative' and 'raw' energy of the handheld style, while 6 sources found it 'nauseating', 'wearying', or 'incomprehensible'. No consistent explanation for the split was evident across sources.
  • Political Messaging: 6 sources found the parallels to modern class struggles 'relevant' and 'urgent', while 4 sources dismissed them as 'subtly', 'simplistic', or 'heavy-handed'. No consistent explanation for the split was evident across sources.

🎯 Who This Product Is For

Reviewer recommendations for different target audiences.

✅
Performance EnthusiastsViewers seeking an intense, emotionally charged lead performance should watch for Andrew Garfield's portrayal.
19 / 19
❌
Casual ViewersThose preferring traditional, mythic, or lighthearted period epics should avoid this due to its relentless bleakness and morose tone.
5 / 19

🔀 Alternatives Mentioned by Reviewers

  • The Death of Robin Hood — Frequently cited as a more cohesive, albeit similarly dour, revisionist take on the folk hero compared to this film's 'forced' origin twist.
  • Peterloo — Recommended for viewers interested in the historical account of suppressed voices and popular revolt, though noted for a similar lack of subtlety.
  • Braveheart — Mentioned as a baseline for the 'emotional mythmaking sweep' that this film consciously rejects in favor of grittier realism.
  • Bloody Sunday — Referenced as a superior example of Paul Greengrass's ability to examine popular revolt with greater thematic clarity.

Alternatives sourced exclusively from reviewer mentions.

✅ Buy This If…

  • You are a fan of Andrew Garfield's acting range and want to see his latest period work.
  • You appreciate visceral, documentary-style action filmmaking over traditional cinematic polish.

❌ Skip This If…

  • You are looking for a definitive, historically accurate Robin Hood origin story.
  • You suffer from motion sickness or find shaky-cam cinematography distracting in action sequences.
⚖️MIXED RECEPTION

The Uprising is a technically ambitious but narratively fractured historical epic defined entirely by Andrew Garfield's exceptional lead performance. While it succeeds in delivering visceral, high-energy battle sequences, it is ultimately hamstrung by a bizarre, forced narrative twist linking it to Robin Hood and a screenplay that lacks emotional depth. Viewers looking for a gritty portrayal of the 1381 revolt may find enough to admire in its production design, but the film's relentless bleakness and divisive visual style make it a challenging, often exhausting watch. It is a film of high-tier acting trapped within a disjointed script that fails to balance its historical aspirations with its modern political ambitions.

📚 Sources Consulted


The Uprising Movie Review: An engaging yet flawed parable of absolute po...

The Uprising is an engaging yet flawed historical parable that shines due to strong performances and technical craftsmanship. However, it falters due to simplistic writing and an anticlimactic, heavy-handed approach to revisionist history.

Comparison: The film's invasion sequence is compared to Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey in terms of its anti-violence message and display of anarchy.

Pros

  • Andrew Garfield delivers a masterful performance
  • Woody Norman is a revelation as Richard II
  • Excellent cinematography and atmospheric music
  • Effective depiction of tension and anarchy

Cons

  • Sluggish start to the film
  • Weak and unconvincing character arc for King Richard II
  • Overly simplistic and convenient screenplay
  • Disruptive and forced revisionist history

The Uprising Review: Andrew Garfield Leads Gritty Historical Epic That F...

The Uprising is a gritty and intense historical epic that effectively draws parallels between 14th-century struggles and modern societal issues. While the performances are strong, particularly from Woody Norman, the film is hampered by overly dark and muddy lighting.

Pros

  • Intense and gripping storyline
  • Strong performances across the cast
  • Powerful thematic resonance with modern society
  • Brilliant portrayal by Woody Norman

Cons

  • Weak and excessively dark lighting
  • Murky visual palette hinders storytelling

The Uprising Review: Paul Greengrass's Film Explores The Complications W...

An intense, unsettling historical drama that effectively explores the complexities and moral decay of a revolution. While the film struggles with broad characterization and a relentless visual style, it remains a substantive study of righteous anger.

Pros

  • Compelling lead performance by Andrew Garfield
  • Visceral, high-energy battle sequences
  • Layered exploration of rebellion and ideology
  • Strong supporting performances from the cast

Cons

  • Ruling establishment depicted in broad, caricatural strokes
  • Kinetic camera style can become wearying
  • Confuses intensity with narrative momentum

Movie Review: Medieval Resistance that may have Inspired Robin Hood — “T...

Paul Greengrass delivers a thought-provoking, immersive historical drama about the Peasants' Revolt. While the film effectively captures the struggle and grit of the era, its narrative follows a predictable trajectory toward inevitable tragedy.

Comparison: The film's politics are described as being as obvious and simplistic as those found in Spartan, Les Miserables, and Peterloo.

Pros

  • Compelling performances from Andrew Garfield and Cosmo Jarvis
  • Deeply immersive atmosphere of the 14th century
  • Thought-provoking exploration of historical class struggles

Cons

  • Simplistic and obvious political messaging
  • Story becomes predictable as it nears the end

MOVIE REVIEW: 'The Uprising' Is A Thrilling, But Emotionally Stunted Per...

The Uprising is a visually impressive and thrilling action-packed period piece that succeeds in its visceral combat but fails to deliver a resonant emotional experience. While the performances are strong, the thin character development prevents the film from reaching its potential as a true epic.

Pros

  • Immersive and visceral action set pieces
  • Strong, nuanced lead performance by Andrew Garfield
  • Effective use of old-fashioned practical effects
  • Terrific supporting performances across the board

Cons

  • Breakneck pace limits character development
  • Lacks necessary emotional depth and resonance
  • Supporting cast given little to do
  • Subpar script regarding character background

AwardsWatch - ‘The Uprising’ Review: The Peasants are Revolting in Paul ...

The Uprising is a gritty and technically impressive historical drama that ultimately feels exhausting and narratively incomplete. While Andrew Garfield delivers a strong, sensitive performance, the film's relentless bleakness and thin character development hinder its overall impact.

Comparison: It is compared to other recent dour films like The Death of Robin Hood and is noted as having similar moral wafflings to Paul Greengrass's previous works like United 93.

Pros

  • Strong performance by Andrew Garfield
  • Visually gritty and textured production design
  • Effective and brutal final act
  • Imposing musical score by Volker Bertelmann

Cons

  • Exhausting onslaught of bleakness
  • Ill-defined character arcs
  • Clunky exposition and pacing issues
  • Limited budget results in rudimentary CG crowds

Movie Review: 'The Uprising' a medieval revolt that speaks to our modern...

Paul Greengrass effectively applies his signature shaky-cam documentary style to a medieval setting. The film uses the 1381 Peasants' Revolt to comment on contemporary social issues.

Pros

  • Innovative use of shaky-cam cinematography
  • Relevant modern thematic parallels
  • Intense, responsive camera work

Cons

    The Uprising Movie Review: You Can Say THAT Again - Stuart Shave, Big Pi...

    Paul Greengrass delivers a visceral historical epic with potent contemporary political relevance and strong performances. However, it struggles with character development and inconsistent visual effects, preventing it from reaching the emotional resonance of a classic rebellion film.

    Comparison: It lacks the emotional mythmaking sweep of 'Braveheart', opting instead for a grittier and more realistic approach to social unrest.

    Pros

    • Compelling and gritty production design
    • Strong, committed performances from lead cast
    • Potent contemporary political resonance
    • Effective portrayal of the chaos of revolt

    Cons

    • Protagonist lacks convincing leadership arc
    • Restless camera work is often distracting
    • Uneven CGI and digital crowd extensions
    • Lacks cohesive emotional and narrative shape

    The Uprising (2026) | Movie Review | Deep Focus Review - deepfocusreview...

    The Uprising is a stirring, tension-filled political film that uses the 1381 Peasants' Revolt to draw potent, albeit unsubtle, parallels to modern inequality and government corruption.

    Comparison: The film is compared to Mike Leigh’s Peterloo for its account of suppressed voices and to The Death of Robin Hood for its deconstruction of the Robin Hood legend.

    Pros

    • Compelling and human performance by Andrew Garfield
    • Effective use of handheld cameras to capture raw energy
    • Strong and relevant political parallels to modern times
    • Rousing musical score by Volker Bertelmann

    Cons

    • Heightened tension can feel exhausting or monotonous
    • Includes some distracting anachronistic digital shots
    • Political messaging can feel somewhat unsubtle

    MOVIE REVIEW: The Uprising — Every Movie Has a Lesson - everymoviehasale...

    Paul Greengrass delivers a tense, historically grounded, and emotionally urgent film that effectively parallels past societal struggles with modern concerns. While Andrew Garfield gives a powerful performance, the decision to force an origin story for the Robin Hood legend feels like a risky and potentially overshadowing narrative choice.

    Comparison: The film attempts a unique approach compared to other depictions of the Robin Hood legend by grounding it in the historical reality of the Peasants' Revolt.

    Pros

    • Expertly captures historical tension and character motivation
    • Bracing and visually compelling filmmaking
    • Strong, impassioned performance by Andrew Garfield
    • Deeply relevant and urgent thematic parallels

    Cons

    • The Robin Hood origin twist feels unnecessary
    • Mythic injection may overshadow the historical lessons

    'The Uprising' Film Review: A Dull Mix of History and Legend - The Movie...

    Paul Greengrass's attempt to draw modern political parallels through a historical lens is undermined by a weak, emotionally vacant screenplay and distracting stylistic choices. Despite strong performances, the film lacks depth and falls short of its potential.

    Comparison: It is compared to 'The Death of Robin Hood' as another redundant revisionist telling of a famous tale this year.

    Pros

    • Features a talented cast of top-tier British actors
    • Cosmo Jarvis delivers an impressive performance
    • Andrew Garfield shows dedication in opening scenes

    Cons

    • Screenplay is debilitatingly under-written and emotionally vacant
    • Shaky-cam direction makes fight sequences incomprehensible
    • Inconsistent tone and lack of character dimension
    • Over-reliance on heavy-handed modern political allegory

    Movie Review: Medieval action drama 'The Uprising' struggles under a Rob...

    The film starts as a compelling historical drama about the Peasants' Revolt but suffers from a bizarre, unnecessary, and chronologically incorrect twist linking it to Robin Hood. Despite strong performances and gritty visuals, this narrative misstep significantly undermines the movie's impact.

    Comparison: It is criticized for being a more somber and less effective take on the folk hero compared to Hugh Jackman’s 'The Death of Robin Hood'.

    Pros

    • Andrew Garfield delivers a committed performance
    • Outstanding acting from Jamie Bell and Cosmo Jarvis
    • Brilliantly authentic and gritty medieval production design
    • Effective use of kinetic, handheld camerawork

    Cons

    • Inexplicable and distracting Robin Hood origin twist
    • Fails to maintain historical consistency
    • The protagonist's character arc feels inconsistent
    • Overly morose tone

    Review: ‘The Uprising’ - Christianity Today - christianitytoday.com...

    The Uprising is a gruesome and poorly executed film that depicts the violent consequences of claiming divine authority. Its shaky cinematography and disjointed narrative fail to provide an enjoyable or coherent viewing experience.

    Pros

      Cons

      • Nauseating shaky camera work
      • Unserious tone in certain moments
      • Excessively gory and violent throughout
      • Poor cinematic execution
      • Confusing marketing and title changes

      Movie Review: Medieval action drama ‘The Uprising’ struggles under a Rob...

      The Uprising is a medieval drama that starts with potential but ultimately fails due to an unnecessary and historically inaccurate Robin Hood origin twist. While it features strong performances and gritty realism, the narrative suffers from severe cinematic overreach.

      Comparison: It is described as a morose take on the folk hero, appearing as an inferior alternative to Hugh Jackman’s The Death of Robin Hood.

      Pros

      • Unflinching commitment from Andrew Garfield
      • Outstanding performances by Jamie Bell and Cosmo Jarvis
      • Gloriously rooted in gritty medieval muck
      • Kinetic and visceral action scenes

      Cons

      • Inexplicable and forced Robin Hood twist
      • Fails to make historical or character sense
      • Overly perfect main character
      • Narrative devolves into cynicism and anarchy

      The Uprising Review: Andrew Garfield Leads a Brutal Historical Epic - Ne...

      The Uprising is a fierce, ambitious historical epic anchored by Andrew Garfield's powerful performance and Paul Greengrass's signature visceral action style. While its pacing falters in the final act, it remains a gripping and intense cinematic experience.

      Pros

      • Outstanding, emotionally charged performance by Andrew Garfield
      • Strong supporting performances from Jamie Bell and Cosmo Jarvis
      • Visceral, intense, and realistic battle sequences
      • Effective portrayal of a vulnerable and unstable young king

      Cons

      • Shaky cinematography makes some action sequences hard to follow
      • Pacing issues during the final act
      • Stop-and-start narrative rhythm near the end

      The Uprising Review: Paul Greengrass’s Gritty Medieval Epic is Marred by...

      The film features a strong performance by Andrew Garfield and effective antagonists, but is significantly hindered by poor visual effects and a disappointing, unearned ending. It remains a visually inconsistent and uneven entry in Paul Greengrass's filmography.

      Comparison: It is described as a hit-or-miss feature that fails to ground itself in the physical, tactile grit found in Greengrass’s previous historical works.

      Pros

      • Energetic lead performance by Andrew Garfield
      • Effective and detestable royal villains
      • Strong acting from supporting cast
      • Visceral thriller elements

      Cons

      • Dreadful and synthetic digital visual effects
      • Flat and sterile cinematography
      • Compromised and unearned third act
      • Excessive 128-minute runtime

      'The Uprising' Review: History finds its pulse - InBetweenDrafts - inbet...

      The Uprising is an urgent and physically engaging period drama that breathes fresh life into historical events through strong performances and propulsive action. While its pacing falters slightly in the final act, it remains a highly entertaining and well-crafted film.

      Comparison: Unlike traditional, static medieval period dramas, this film rejects genre tropes in favor of modern action filmmaking and relentless momentum.

      Pros

      • Physically committed lead performance by Andrew Garfield
      • Strong ensemble cast with compelling character dynamics
      • Clear and well-choreographed action sequences
      • Successfully balances spectacle with meaningful emotional stakes

      Cons

      • Runtime is overly long at two and a half hours
      • Back stretch contains repetitive and lingering sequences

      ‘The Uprising’ review: A stirring Andrew Garfield is unable to energise ...

      Despite a stirring performance from Andrew Garfield, Paul Greengrass's historical drama is ultimately a listless and disjointed film. It fails to generate the tension required to make the subject matter feel urgent or impactful.

      Comparison: The film recalls the director's 2002 work 'Bloody Sunday' in its examination of popular revolt and government crackdowns, though it lacks the same thematic clarity.

      Pros

      • Andrew Garfield delivers a stirring and modest performance
      • Impressive flair for hand-to-hand combat scenes
      • Assured and well-edited extended battle sequence

      Cons

      • Lack of inspired and tense filmmaking
      • Protagonist lacks a meaningful dramatic arc
      • Supporting characters feel like thin caricatures
      • Disappointing finale relies on tired blockbuster conventions

      'The Uprising' Review: Andrew Garfield Stars In Paul Greengrass Epic - d...

      Paul Greengrass delivers a compelling and socially relevant action epic that manages to be both a period piece and a sharp commentary on modern class divides. With a standout performance from Andrew Garfield, the film is an urgent, well-paced, and thought-provoking experience.

      Comparison: Distinguished from recent, darker Robin Hood-themed films by offering a more rip-roaring, politically charged journey into the 1381 peasant rebellion.

      Pros

      • Strong, dignified performance by Andrew Garfield
      • Expertly staged and urgent action sequences
      • Relevant political themes mirrored in today's society
      • High production values across cinematography and score

      Cons

      • Subject matter can feel grim and reflective
      • Pacing may feel intense for some viewers

      The Uprising Review: Harrowing, Heartbreaking, And A Great Modern Epic -...

      The Uprising is a stirring and timely historical epic that uses 14th-century class conflict to mirror modern political struggles. Despite slightly underdeveloped portrayals of its villainous ruling class, strong performances and effective drama make it a riveting experience.

      Comparison: The review notes that The Uprising achieves the historical epic scale that Gladiator II failed to capture.

      Pros

      • Terrific central performance by Andrew Garfield
      • Compelling supporting cast and character depth
      • Effective drama and well-constructed action sequences
      • Relevant, timely thematic weight regarding class disparity

      Cons

      • Ruling class characters feel cartoonishly cruel
      • Broad strokes in depicting powerful figures

      'The Uprising' Review: Andrew Garfield's 'No Kings' Drama Lacks Courage ...

      The Uprising is a boring and muddy historical drama that fails to capture the courage of the Peasants' Revolt. Despite solid performances from the cast, the film's lack of narrative boldness results in a bland, unsatisfying cinematic experience.

      Pros

      • Strong performances from Jamie Bell and Thomasin McKenzie
      • Dynamic and energetic handheld cinematography

      Cons

      • Bland and boring narrative
      • Overly simplified black-and-white morality
      • Maudlin tone and muddy visual style

      MOVIE REVIEW: ‘Lisabi the Uprising’ is Nollywood’s best epic yet - premi...

      Lisabi: The Uprising is a compelling and high-quality Nollywood epic that effectively brings historical resistance to life. It serves as a strong cinematic achievement with an impressive narrative flow.

      Pros

      • Impressive storytelling from start to finish
      • Strong directorial vision by Niyi Akinmolayan
      • Powerful historical narrative
      • Excellent lead performance by Lateef Adedimeji

      Cons